Paul,
I've been using a Tioga on my 3wt for years. No complaints at all, but then I am not landing steelhead with it either.
The only thing I would say is to compare the price to the battenkill. I think it's a couple bucks more expensive than the Orvis reel.
I got mine at Clouser's shop, and if you decide on that reel I would go there. Bob's always helped me with everything I have bought there.